An asp at the breast
of democracy
Wealth has responsibility
as well as privilege.
The same applies to
control. Used well,
by governments, corporations,
or individuals, it can
maintain, uphold, and
protect standards and
freedoms. Badly used,
it neglects, downgrades,
and undermines those
same standards and freedoms.
Following the precept
of the first Canadian
Vindicator of Daniel
Tracey as laid out in
its masthead motto,
"Justice to all
classes; monopolies
and exclusive privileges
to none," the recent
removal of Russell Mills
from his position as
publisher of the
Ottawa Citizen newspaper
calls for condemnation
by all who treasure
freedom of the Press
in Canada.
The Citizen is
one of a chain of newspapers
and television stations
controlled by one company,
CanWest. This concentration
of ownership of the
printed and later of
the electronic media
is nothing new, particularly
where Canadians are
involved. A litany of
names starts with Atkin
(Lord Beaverbrook),
and goes on through
Thomson (Baron Thomson
of Fleet), Irving, Black
(Lord Black of Crossharbour),
and Asper. Undoubtedly
all worked hard, with
might and main, to achieve
their business goals.
As owners they enjoyed
the right and freedom
to hire and fire whomever
the chose. They had
that control, but how
it was exercised in
the case of Mills and
the Citizen was
an example of the crudest
kind of control.
An edict was issued that
the company was free
to insist that editorials
it produced at head
office must appear in
the newspapers it controlled.
It was, at best, a heavy
handed imposition. The
edict was obeyed, but
the Citizen distinguished
between company editorials
and the editorials written
by its staff.
Mills published an editorial,
the product of the Citizen's
editorial board, outlining
reasons why the current
Prime Minister of Canada
should resign.
In a bizarre sequence
of events that followed,
he was awarded an honorary
degree by Carleton University,
citing his career in
journalism. He gave
the convocation address
to graduating students
on the subject of freedom
of the Press. That was
at a Saturday conferring
ceremony. Next day,
Sunday, he was dismissed
by CanWest.
CanWest is a supporter
of the Prime Minister.
Freedom of the Press
was won in Canada by
courageous journalists
such as Daniel Tracey
and Ludger Duvernay
of La Minerve,
both of whom suffered
imprisonment, Dr. Edmund
Bailey O'Callaghan who
edited the Vindicator
during Tracey's imprisonment,
Francis Collins of The
Canadian Freeman,
imprisoned by a Family
Compact dominated court,
and Joseph Howe of the
Novascotian.
Russell Mills is the
latest to be numbered
in that distinguished
company.
As an aside, readers
will find a play on
this web site titled
The
Whole Damn Lot,
based on the trial and
imprisonment of Francis
Collins. The foreword
is quite apropos in
present circumstances.
And readers will remember
the last Egyptian pharaoh,
Cleopatra, who for a
time enjoyed complete
control, used it badly,
and died when bitten
by an asp at her breast.
Home
| About
| Canadian Vindicator
| Literature
| Gallery
| History
|